CONNECT WITH:

Florida Bulldog
Matt Gaetz Photo: AP

By Bob Norman, FloridaBulldog.org

A federal magistrate judge has rejected a victim’s effort to unseal court records identifying an unindicted co-conspirator in the criminal case against now-imprisoned former Seminole County Tax Collector Joel Greenberg, ruling that protecting the co-conspirator’s reputation outweighs the public’s right to know.

The Nov. 12 ruling by U.S. Magistrate Judge Leslie Hoffman Price is the latest setback in efforts to shed more light on the wide-ranging Greenberg corruption and sex-trafficking investigation, which led to an 11-year prison sentence for the ex-tax collector and gained national notoriety in part due to the involvement of Matt Gaetz, the ex-Congressman and briefly President Trump’s choice for U.S. Attorney General.

Ironically, the co-conspirator being protected by the government participated in destroying another person’s reputation. Court records revealed the unidentified person joined Greenberg in smearing former teacher Brian Beute, who ran against Greenberg in 2020. Greenberg was convicted of stalking Beute after he and the co-conspirator sent wholly fabricated allegations of sexual misconduct to the school where Beute was working and, pretending to be the teacher, created fake social media accounts promoting white supremacy. 

It was Beute who filed the motion to identify the co-conspirator arguing the public has a “substantial interest in understanding the full scope of conduct in this case” and that he has a right to know who participated in crimes against him.

“The record shows that the co-conspirator was involved in the original attacks on me, in the letter that went to the school claiming that I raped a boy and the fake [social media] accounts,” Beute told the Florida Bulldog. “The government used the co-conspirator in its case against Joel Greenberg. That means the person’s name is subject to being disclosed.” 

Judge Price, who sits in Orlando, determined instead that the co-conspirator should be protected from reputational harm. Her decision will be reviewed by Senior U.S. District Judge Gregory Presnell, the presiding judge on the case.

Brian Beute

“[I]f the person’s identity were now to be made public, the person most assuredly would be treated and stigmatized as a criminal – without ever actually being charged and without any opportunity to provide a defense,” Price wrote in her ruling. “Such harm clearly outweighs the interests of Mr. Beute and the public in knowing the unindicted co-conspirator’s identity.”

A DIZZYING ARRAY OF CRIMES THAT LED TO GAETZ

The Greenberg criminal case began with the Beute stalking allegations but grew into a sprawling federal investigation that revealed Greenberg exploited his public office to commit a dizzying array of crimes that included misappropriating public funds, identity theft, financial fraud and the sexual exploitation of financially vulnerable young women.

And it ultimately led to Gaetz, then a rising star in the Republican Party and close congressional ally of Donald Trump. After initially being charged for stalking Beute, Greenberg cooperated with the government and alleged Gaetz had sex for pay with several young women, including an underaged 17-year-old girl.

Despite evidence that included Venmo payments made to the women by the congressman, the feds filed no charges against Gaetz, which prompted the House Ethics Committee to begin its own investigation. 

While that investigation was active, Trump nominated Gaetz to be the Attorney General of the United States on Nov. 13, 2024. Facing bipartisan opposition, Gaetz, who resigned his congressional seat, withdrew his name from consideration just eight days later. 

The following month the findings of the ethics investigation were released – and they were damning. The committee found that between 2017 and 2020 Gaetz spent a total of $90,000 for sex with multiple women, including the underaged girl. It also found he’d used illicit drugs, including cocaine and ecstasy, during this time, and received improper gifts. 

Just last month, two of the women filed a federal lawsuit in Orlando against Gaetz, Greenberg, and former Republican state Rep. Chris Dorworth alleging they were sex-trafficked by the three men in a scheme to recruit young women, pay them for sex, supply them with drugs and arrange travel and lodging in exchange for sexual activity.

“I look forward to taking the plaintiffs’ depositions because much of the conduct alleged against me is false,” Gaetz wrote Politico in a response to the lawsuit. “The lawsuit relies almost exclusively on a Congressional committee report that didn’t allow me to confront my accusers. Now I will finally have that chance.”

From left to right, Roger Stone, Matt Gaetz and Joel Greenberg

WHO IS THE CO-CONSPIRATOR?

While it’s still very much a mystery, speculation about the identity of the unindicted co-conspirator has centered on former Republican operative Jacob Engels, Dorworth and Gaetz himself. 

While messages requesting comment left with Gaetz and Dorworth hadn’t been returned prior to press time, Engels denied he was the unindicted co-conspirator when reached Sunday by phone by the Florida Bulldog. 

“I feel for brother Beute, but it wasn’t me,” Engels said. “I went through the grand jury process. I  was fingerprinted, I did a handwriting exemplar, I did a saliva sample. And they determined there is nothing that would lead anyone to believe I am that person.”

Engels, who recently entered a court diversion program after pleading guilty to methamphetamine charges, publicly participated in the smear campaign against Buete while he ran against Greenberg. Engels publicly alleged on his now-dormant political hit website Central Florida Post that Beute had engaged in inappropriate sexual misconduct with male students.

Not only was Engels associated with Greenberg and Dorworth, but he also worked for long-time Trump political consultant Roger Stone, a Fort Lauderdale resident who is well-known for orchestrating smears involving fictitious sexual misconduct allegations. 

While facing the federal investigation, Greenberg attempted to pay Stone  $250,000 in exchange for his help in securing a pardon from Trump.

Still without answers, Beute said he’s filing an objection to Price’s ruling with the presiding judge in the case, Gregory Presnell. During his sentencing of Greenberg, Presnell singled out the Beute stalking case as “downright evil.” Beute said he’s yet to recover from the damage done by the smear campaign.  

“It put me mentally in a tailspin, it affected my children, affected my profession, I’m no longer an educator,” said Beute, who now lives out of state. “It affected my entire life.” 

He said if Presnell rejects his objection, he’ll likely file an appeal.

“I can’t pursue my civil right to go after a person that equally or partly participated in Joel Greenberg’s crimes against me,” Beute said. “Joel Greenberg is in prison, and this person is free and unidentified. As an unindicted co-conspirator, that means he committed a crime against me. But this judge is saying no, the unindicted co-conspirator is innocent. They can’t have it both ways.”

Support Florida Bulldog

If you believe in the value of watchdog journalism, please make your tax-deductible contribution today.

We are a 501(c)(3) organization. All donations are tax deductible.

Join Our Email List

Email
*

First Name

Last Name

Florida Bulldog delivers fact-based watchdog reporting as a public service that’s essential to a free and democratic society. We are nonprofit, independent, nonpartisan, experienced. No fake news here.


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

×

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Email
*

First Name

Last Name