Florida Bulldog

Hallandale city manager’s going away gift of public money to departing commissioner

By William Gjebre, 

Hallandale Beach City Manager Renee Miller, ex-Vice Mayor Alexander Lewy
Hallandale Beach City Manager Renee Miller, ex-Vice Mayor Alexander Lewy

Thanks to Hallandale Beach City Manager Renee Miller’s generosity, former Vice Mayor Alexander Lewy collected a tidy gift of taxpayer cash after he quit the city commission last May before his term was finished.

To make it happen, Miller liberally interpreted a new and controversial city rule that commissioners’ enacted last year. The rule allows them to pocket thousands of unspent city dollars every year from their annual travel accounts.

“I made judgment calls,” Miller said when asked about the city’s $5,253 farewell payout to Lewy.

Miller said she decided Lewy was entitled to a payout even though he left his commission seat just seven months into the fiscal year. Likewise, she acknowledged hiking Lewy’s payout by raising his yearly travel account to $15,000. Commissioners’ standard travel budget per year is $10,000.

“I didn’t ask for it,” said Lewy, who quit to work for a lobbying group. He pointed out that he voted against allowing city commissioners to be paid for unused travel funds.

Lewy compared the travel fund payouts to other city benefits, like health insurance. “It’s not my fault that I benefited by it,” Lewy said. “I didn’t receive anything I didn’t deserve.”

Lewy said the commission authorized the increase to $15,000 as a way of providing additional funds for the mayor and commissioners who travel more on city business, but the approved resolution says each would receive $10,000 apiece. The city manager was also authorized to establish “an additional travel account” to cover such travel.

At the July 2013 meeting where the new travel policy vote was taken, Miller suggested $5,000 more for Mayor Joy Cooper plus an additional $5,000 for those traveling frequently on behalf of the city, according to city commission video.

In interviews, Commissioners Michele Lazarow and William Julian raised concerns about Miller’s payout to Lewy. Each said the city administration should have asked the commission’s approval before increasing a commissioner’s travel budget beyond $10,000.

“It was not voted up,” Lazarow said, adding the higher budget for Lewy “is a surprise.”

“It’s not right to get money if he leaves” before the end of the budget year, Julian said. He said the notion that anyone would leave early wasn’t contemplated when the policy was adopted.

Without consulting the commission, Miller said she decided to pay Lewy for unused travel on a prorated basis for the year. She also authorized $15,000 travel accounts for both Lewy and Cooper, who also voted against the travel payout policy, because they were tasked with attending numerous local, state and national conferences and meetings on the city’s behalf.

When Lewy quit he’d only spent $3,497 of the $10,000 in his city account. Miller, however, pro-rated his payout based on a $15,000 travel budget.

The city manager’s calculations allowed Lewy to receive nearly $3,000 more than he would have had his benefit been calculated using the standard $10,000 travel budget.

In 2012-2013, both Cooper and Lewy traveled extensively on the city’s behalf, each exceeding their $10,000 travel budget. The commission approved an extra $5,000 for both that year.

Records show that through Aug. 18, Cooper had spent $10,814 in travel. If she spends no more by the end of the fiscal year on Sept. 30, she’ll be entitled to a payout of $4,186 from her $15,000 travel account. The fiscal year ends Sept. 30.

Here is the comparable travel spending for the three commissioners who voted to approve the travel policy. The number in parentheses is the current amount each would be due after Sept. 30: William Julian, $277 ($9,723); Michele Lazarow, $2,333 ($7,667); Anthony Sanders, $3,844 ($6,156).

Commissioner Leo Grachow, appointed by the commission in May to fill Lewy’s seat, has a $5,000 travel account this year. He’s spent $76, and stands to collect $4,924 after Sept 30.


Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Support Florida Bulldog

If you believe in the value of watchdog journalism please make your tax-deductible contribution today.

We are a 501(c)(3) organization. All donations are tax deductible.

Join Our Email List


First Name

Last Name

Florida Bulldog delivers fact-based watchdog reporting as a public service that’s essential to a free and democratic society. We are nonprofit, independent, nonpartisan, experienced. No fake news here.


6 responses to “Hallandale city manager’s going away gift of public money to departing commissioner”

  1. So the worthless Miller took it upon herself to establish an “additional travel account” for an outgoing commissioner who claims he was not even asking for it! Travel budgets are intended for travel and are not supposed to be used for going away gifts! Isn’t it reassuring that we have an arrogant lightweight like Miller looking out for the public interest? Why didn’t she offer up part of her own inflated salary? There needs to be an intense and thorough investigation of this corrupt city…and I believe it is in the works. They have played “loose and fast” with taxpayer money, starting with their dirty CRA…so in their minds…what’s another $5,300?

    Joy Cooper’s lapdog was once an economic development manager in the rotten-to-the-core (and also under investigation) City of Lauderdale Lakes…so doing the wrong thing and flouting the law…comes quite naturally to her!

  2. A license to steal tax payers money. This is why
    these people go into politics. They are unable to
    hold down a real job.

  3. And the ex-Vice Mayor acts like the money was forced upon him by Miller. Here’s a novel idea Mr. Lewy: Give the money back! It doesn’t belong to you and was only intended for travel expenses! Just because Miller is a corrupt nitwit, doesn’t mean that you have to be one too. And if you don’t return your “gift” and choose to run for office again…we will remember!

  4. How many lap dances at Cheetahs does $5,253 buy?

  5. They are all corrupted. Stealing from the Hallandale tax payers. Their hunting dogs like Shelly and the other code enforcement officers penalize hard working people. While the mayor upgrades her mansion without permits

  6. A watchdog is necessary to keep government in line. A very important part of being a watchdog is get the facts straight. When someone who holds themselves up as a watchdog starts getting facts wrong, everything must come into question. Being accurate is critical to being a successful watchdog, and in this case, the reporter totally misstated the facts.

    The reimbursement to Commissioners for unpaid travel expenses is not at the City Manager’s discretion. City Manager Miller just followed what the Commission mandated in 2013. In Hallandale Beach, each Commissioner and the Mayor are given a $10,000 a year travel budget. If that is exceeded, the Commission routinely gives that Commissioner or the Mayor another $5,000. In July of 2013, Commissioner Sanders proposed giving the Commissioners and the Mayor any money that was left at the end of the year from their travel allowance. It passed by a 3-2 vote. The two opposing the proposal were Vice Mayor Lewy and Mayor Cooper. Commissioners Sanders, Julian and Lazarow were the ones that were in favor of the change. Both Commissioner Julian and Lazarow were quoted as saying that it was a way to get Commissioners extra income without raising their pay. So, this was not City Manager Miller deciding to give Vice Mayor Lewy a going away gift, this was City Manager Miller doing what Commissioners Lazarow, Julian and Sanders instructed her to do.

    If you are going to be an effective watchdog, get your facts straight.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Subscribe to our Newsletter


First Name

Last Name