Florida Bulldog

With millions at stake, Broward and Miami-Dade compete with charter schools for students

By William Gjebre,

With more students expected to enroll in charter schools this coming year and millions of dollars at stake, Broward and Miami-Dade public schools officials are seeking to stem the flow of students by promoting specials schools and programs.

For the second year in a row more than 7,000 additional students are expected to enter Broward and Miami-Dade charter schools in a few months, siphoning off $40-$50 million in state money from Florida’s two largest school districts.

Now seeing themselves in active competition with charters schools, both districts are fighting back to keep students and the dollars they represent.

Merrie Meyers, Director of the Broward district’s Parents, Business and Community Partnership Program, said the district has asked principals to conduct programs that highlight the quality of Broward public schools.

Meyers said parents who have been pleased with the education their children have been asked to help promote district-run schools to parents of incoming students – particularly those entering middle or high school.

The district, Meyers said, also has expanded special programs within various schools, highlighting science, technology and other studies, as well as created regional and countywide magnet schools and programs.

In addition, Meyers said, the district has pointed out the experience and advanced degree work of teachers and awards won by students.

Miami-Dade’s new programs

In Miami-Dade, the district has created additional countywide magnet schools, special programs or academies at existing schools, expanded the number of K-8 schools favored by parents, and established a virtual school in downtown.

In addition, it has allowed some 15,000 students to attend schools where their parents work or near their parents’ workplace. One school, Ada Merritt K-8, has no boundaries; it’s a school for students of parents working in the downtown area.

“We have a great deal of diversity,” said Richard Hinds, Miami-Dade Public Schools Associate Superintendent/Chief Financial Officer.

Both school districts made considerable gains last year in statewide testing. And both districts are among five finalists for the annual, national Broad Prize, awarding the winner $500,000 in college scholarships for graduating 2012 high school seniors. The prize honors urban school districts making the greatest performance and improvement in student achievement while overcoming income and ethnic achievement issues.

Despite the initiatives by the two districts, charter school enrollments are expected to increase again in the coming year.

Charter schools are a hybrid of public and private schools. Although they are privately operated, they receive state money based on student population and operate with limited oversight by the public school districts. In Florida, state money follows the student to either traditional public schools or to charter schools.

“We’d like to see our students stay in our schools,” said Lee Black, of the Broward public schools budget office. “The money and expenses follow the students.”

This school year, 2010-2011, student enrollment in 68 charter schools in Broward totaled 23,274.

More students, more charter schools

Broward schools public information officer Marsy Smith said 14 additional charter schools are expected to be added in the upcoming school year, 2011-2012. They could increase enrollment by 1,874, to a total of 25,148, an 8 percent increase over the previous year. That student increase would result in a loss of more than $11 million in funding for the district.

However, the district’s budget department said that based on information provided by charter schools, Broward is budgeting for a total of 29,694 students, an increase of nearly 28 percent, Black said.

She observed, however, that in past years charter schools have over-estimated enrollment increases.

A more realistic increase, Black said, would be about 13 percent, the increase during the current school year. If that occurs, the enrollment spike for 2011-2012 would be 3,026, to a total of 26,300 students.  That student increase would result in a loss of more than $18 million in funding for the district.

“You plan for the worst and hope for the best,” Black said.

In Miami-Dade, enrollment this school year in 92 charter schools was 35,306. With 12 additional charter schools expected to open for 2011-2012, the district is bracing and budgeting for 5,350 additional students in charter school, to a total of 40,656, a 15 percent increase – the same percentage hike for the current school year.  That student increase would result in a loss of more than $30 million in funding for the district.

While the district would lose considerable funds if an additional 5,350 students attend charters in the coming year, Hinds said the district does not incur expenses for teachers and other employees. He also said,  the overall loss of funds to the district annually based on charter school student enrollment is “over $200 million” and any additional students adds to that figure.

The anticipated enrollment increases in the two counties comes as the Florida Legislature has eased regulations for establishing new charter schools and expanding existing ones.

The Charter School program was enacted in 1996 by state statute and gives parents and students an alternative to public schools. The tuition free schools are created through an agreement between the schools and the district school boards. State funds are funneled to charter schools through the district school boards.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Support Florida Bulldog

If you believe in the value of watchdog journalism please make your tax-deductible contribution today.

We are a 501(c)(3) organization. All donations are tax deductible.

Join Our Email List


First Name

Last Name

Florida Bulldog delivers fact-based watchdog reporting as a public service that’s essential to a free and democratic society. We are nonprofit, independent, nonpartisan, experienced. No fake news here.


5 responses to “With millions at stake, Broward and Miami-Dade compete with charter schools for students”

  1. Lisa Shelly Avatar

    Even though the reporting here is a little better than the Scum-Sentinel, it is still incomplete. Funding for students in charter schools is a percentage of the state funding per student–I believe, but admit I’m not completely sure, that charter schools receive approximately 60% of the per-student funding.

    The public school system should be welcoming charters–they are giving up 100% of the student, but only 60% of the money. This reduces class sizes, frees up $$ for teachers–and it’s on the charter school to educate the student with a big reduction in cash.

    The fact that charters are able to do so ought to give the public school system pause–same kids, same pool of teachers, same unions–different results?

    Shouldn’t our public school system be figuring that out??

  2. Lisa – Funding for a charter school student, in any given district in the state, is equal to that received for a public school student. The local school district, however, retains a 5% fee, so that the total is about 95%, not 60%.

  3. Lisa Shelly Avatar

    William–If you dig a little deeper, you find the following: ” In addition, traditional public schools receive a steady stream of tax-generated funds for repairs, renovations and capital equipment, and for building new facilities. Charter schools do not have equal access to these funds. Instead, new charter schools have to rely on operating funds to pay for their facility and capital equipment. Charter schools that have operated for 3 or more years or are part of a feeder pattern can apply for “capital outlay” funds but only if they meet certain rigid criteria.” (source; . I also found this document that has exhaustive detail on the DOE website;

    Charter schools do not get the same amount of money per student as do public schools.

    Additionally, basic educational goals are not being met by Broward schools. A case in point; my tenth grader never learned to write in cursive in public school! Why? His third grade teacher ran out of time to teach it. The fourth grade teacher’s response was ” he should have learned that last year. Here, work with him at home”, and handed me a 2 inch stack of worksheets. The principal basically did nothing, backed up the teacher (preparing for FCAT was job 1), and we had to teach him.

    That is why charter schools are flourishing. They should.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Subscribe to our Newsletter


First Name

Last Name