Broward’s new Community Court looks to keep non-violent offenders out of jail

chief judge

By Noreen Marcus, 

Broward Chief Judge Jack Tuter Photo: J.A.A.B Blog

Broward is launching a new court to help keep non-violent lawbreakers out of jail.

The “Community Court” is getting a jump-start with a $200,000 grant from the Center for Court Innovation, a nonprofit that supports outside-the-box solutions to problems within the justice system.

In a first for Florida, Broward’s 17th Judicial Circuit is one of five such federal grant recipients across the nation. The nonprofit center partners with the U.S. Department of Justice’s Bureau of Justice Assistance.

“Our court is focused on therapeutic treatment for people charged with non-violent crimes,” said Chief Judge Jack Tuter, who pushed for the grant. “The idea is to have service providers in the courtroom.” Arranging for homeless people picked up on municipal code violations to go directly to shelters, for example, avoids pre-trial jail warehousing.

The first court is slated to open for business in January in Fort Lauderdale, where the bulk of the county’s homeless population lives. Last year there were 2,450 individuals living on the streets of Broward County, more than half of them in Fort Lauderdale, the county reported.

The Fort Lauderdale venue is just the start, Tuter said. “We want to move it around. It is basically moving the court to where the population is.”

Working together

The Broward court system, the city of Fort Lauderdale and Broward County are working together on the new court, Tuter said. Jeri Pryor, homeless intervention administrator for Fort Lauderdale, was the successful grant-writer. The money will be used to hire a program manager and for other start-up costs.

Tuter learned about the availability of community court grants at a May conference in Birmingham, Ala. “Community courts seek to improve neighborhood safety and engage residents in solving local problems,” the center’s website says. “Researchers have documented that community courts help to reduce recidivism and the use of jail while improving public trust in justice.”

The first community court opened in 1993 in Midtown, Manhattan, and now there are more than two-dozen – held in libraries and other non-traditional venues.

Long before seeking the grant, the chief judge was keenly aware of the connection between homelessness and pre-trial incarceration. Late last year, the subject received some attention when Broward Outreach Center shelters stopped accepting referrals from Mental Health Court. Following complaints from its administrator, Judge Ginger Lerner-Wren, the center resumed taking referrals.

However, that didn’t solve the system-wide problem, Tuter acknowledged at the time. “There’s something wrong with housing people in the jail who have committed minor, non-violent offenses,” he said.

It’s also expensive. Tuter said jail costs about $140 per prisoner per day, far more than halfway houses that require residents to find work and start paying rent, or leave.

The chief judge responded to the problem by assigning a full-time first-appearance judge to focus on pre-trial release and other methods of keeping people out of custody unless and until they are convicted.

He knew there were limits to how much the court could accomplish independently. “It’s a societal issue that the county and city will have to wrestle with,” Tuter said.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Latest comment

  • Well when i was on the otherside of the law it was no money( bond) no honey.So what u r saying is this grant will pay for their bonds.Ok.So who then supervise s them when they are out on bond.Then u state Ft.lau is involved with this as well.I think admin
    officals should stick to and put energies and resources directed to running the city, not playing getting involved when someone gets arrested.Let the courts handle that.All this direction to helping out people who break the law, i say alot of them are better off in jail and then through the intake procedures then placing them in structured settings to get the ast.and help they need.All this chatter about giving esp.homeless free apts, furniture, paying utility bills is not the route i would go.Think give someone a fish they eat for today, show them how to fish, they eat forever.My way works.Trust me..

leave a comment


Subscribe to our Newsletter


First Name

Last Name